Kaymak Sümeyraa, Yerliyurt Kaanb
aAnkara, Turkey
bTokat Gaziosmanpaşa University, Department of Prosthodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Tokat, Turkey
Summary
Background/Aim: The aim of this study is to examine with finite element analysis the distal bar extension, the bar substructure material type and the amount of bar substructure-abutment mismatch, and the stress caused by the implant at the surrounding bone tissue in bar-retained prostheses. Material and Methods: A bar-retained prosthesis model has been designed on three implants placed in the fully toothless lower jaw at the places of both canines and the midline. Bar holder according to distal cantilever lengths was modeled to be 0 mm, 8 mm and 14 mm. The vertical incompatibility of the bar holder substructure with the abutment was modeled to be 0 µm, 100 µm and 200 µm. A total of twenty-seven (3x3x3) different models were obtained with three different bar infrastructure materials (titanium, gold and chromium-cobalt). 150 N occlusal force was applied to the central fossa of the left 1st molar tooth with a rigid food stuff. Results: In the cortical bone, the highest maximum principle stress value (2.78 MPa) was analyzed around the anterior implant socket in the model 13 (gold, cantilever 0mm, misfit 100 µm). The highest von Mises stress value (343.43 MPa, which occurred at the selected joints in bar holders) was observed in model 27 (chrome-cobalt, cantilever 14mm, misfit 200 µm). Conclusions: When the length of the cantilever is 14 mm, it causes a significant increase in stress around the implant, especially near the cantilever. It has been observed that bar infrastructures with high elastic modulus create higher stress values.
Keywords: Dental Implant; Finite Element Analysis; Overdenture
Reference
Abreu, R.T., Spazzin, A.O., Noritomi, P.Y., Consani, R.L.X., Mesquita, M.F. (2010) Influence of Material of Overdentureretaining Bar with Vertical Misfit on Three-Dimensional Stress Distribution. J Prosthodont, 19: 425-431
Assif, D., Marshak, B., Schmidt, A. (1996) Accuracy of Implant Impression Techniques. Implant Dent, 11: 216-222
Attard, N.J., Zarb, G.A. (2004) Long-Term Treatment Outcomes in Edentulous Patients with Implant Overdentures: The Toronto Study. Int J Prosthodont, 17: 425-433
Bacchi, A., Consani, R.L.X., Mesquita, M.F., Santos, M.B.F. (2013) Effect of Framework Material and Vertical Misfit on Stress Distribution in Implant-supported Partial Prosthesis Under Load Application: 3-D Finite Element Analysis. Acta Odontol Scand, 71: 1243-1249
Barão, V.A.R., Delben, J.A., Lima, J., Cabral, T., Assunção, W.G. (2013) Comparison of Different Designs of Implant-retained Overdentures and Fixed Full-Arch Implant-Supported Prosthesis on Stress Distribution in Edentulous Mandible: A Computed Tomography-Based Three-Dimensional Finite Element Analysis. J Biomech, 46(7): 1312-1320
Barão, V.A.R., Gonçalves, A.W., Fernardo, T.L., Aparecida, D.J., Alves, G.E., Capello, S.E.A., Passos, R.E. (2009) Finite Element Analysis to Compare Complete Denture and Implant-Retained Overdentures with Different Attachment Systems. J Craniofac Surg, 20: 1066-1071
Branemark, P.I. (1983) Osseointegration and Its Experimental Background. J Prosthet Dent, 50(3): 399-410
Caetano, C.R., Mesquita, M.F., Consani, R.L.X., Sobrinho, L.C., Santos, M.B.F. (2015) Overdenture Retaining Bar Stress Distribution: A Finite-Element Analysis. Acta Odontol Scand, 73: 274-279
Caldas, R.A., Pfeifer, C.S.C., Bacchi, A., Santos, M.B.F., Reginato, V.F., Consani, R.L.X. (2018) Implant Inclination and Horizontal Misfit in Metallic Bar Framework of Overdentures: Analysis by 3D-FEA Method. Braz Dent J, 29: 166-172
Carlsson, G.E. (2009) Dental Occlusion: Modern Concepts and Their Application in Implant Prosthodontics. Odontology, 97(1): 8-17
Carr, A.B., Gerard, D.A., Larsen, P.E. (1996) The Response of Bone in Primates Around Unloaded Dental Implants Supporting Prostheses with Different Levels of Fit. J Prosthet Dent, 76: 500-509
Davodi, A., Nishimura, R., Beumer, J. (1997) An Implant-Supported Fixed-Removable Prosthesis with a Milled Tissue Bar and Hader Clip Retention as a Restorative Option for the Edentulous Maxilla. J Prosthet Dent, 78(2): 212-217
Doundoulakis, J.H., Eckert, S.E., Lindquist, C.C., Jeffcoat, M.K. (2003) The Implant-Supported Overdenture as an Alternative to the Complete Mandibular Denture. J Am Dent Assoc, 134(11): 1455-1458
Ebadian, B., Mosharraf, V.K.N. (2016) Effect of Cantilever Length on Stress Distribution Around Implants in Mandibular Overdentures Supported by Two and Three Implants. Eur J Dent, 10: 333-340
Elsyad, M.A., Al-Mahdy, Y.F., Salloum, M.G., Elsaih, E.A. (2013) The Effect of Cantilevered Bar Length on Strain Around Two Implants Supporting a Mandibular Overdenture. Implant Dent, 28: e143-e150
Hellden, L.B., Ericson, G., Olsson, C.O. (2005) The Cresco Bridge and Implant Concept: Presentation of a Technology for Fabrication of Abutment-Free, Passively Fitting Superstructures. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent, 25: 89-94
Jemt, T., Book, K. (1996) Prosthesis Misfit and Marginal Bone Loss in Edentulous Patients. Implant Dent, 11: 620-625
Kan, J.Y., Rungcharassaeng, K., Bohsali, K., Goodacre, C.J., Lang, B.R. (1999) Clinical Methods for Evaluating Implant Framework Fit. J Prosthet Dent, 81: 7-13
Misch, C.E. Prosthetic Options in Implant Dentistry. u: Misch C.E. [ur.] Dental Implant Prosthetics, St. Louis, 2nd ed
Mochalski, J., Fröhls, C., Keilig, L., Bourauel, C., Dörsam, I. (2020) Experimental and Numerical Investigations of Fracture and Fatigue Behaviour of Implant-Supported Bars with Distal Extension Made of Three Different Materials. Biomed Eng Biomed Tech, 66: 305-316
Naert, I., Gizani, S., Vuylsteke, M., van Steenberghe, D. (1999) A 5-Year Prospective Randomized Clinical Trial on the Influence of Splinted and Unsplinted Oral Implants Retaining a Mandibular Overdenture: Prosthetic Aspects and Patient Satisfaction. J Oral Rehabil, 26(3): 195-202
Naert, I.E., Hooghe, M., Quirynen, M., van Steenberghe, D. (1997) The Reliability of Implant-Retained Hinging Overdentures for the Fully Edentulous Mandible: An Up to 9-Year Longitudinal Study. Clin Oral Investig, 1(3): 119-124
Rubo, J.H., Capello, S.E.A. (2010) Finite-Element Analysis of Stress on Dental Implant Prosthesis. Clin Implant Dent Relat Res, 12(2): 105-113
Sadowsky, S.J. (2001) Mandibular Implant-Retained Overdentures: A Literature Review. J Prosthet Dent, 86(5): 468-473
Santos, M.B.F., Caldas, R.A., Zen, B.M., Bacchi, A., Sobrinho, L.C. (2015) Adaptation of Overdenture-bars Casted in Different Metals and Their Influence on the Stress Distribution: A Laboratory and 3D FEA. J Biomech, 48: 8-13
Santos, M.B.F., Bacchi, A., Consani, R.L.X., Sobrinho, L.C. (2015) Influence of Diamondlike Carbon Coating of Screws on Axial Tightening Force and Stress Distribution on Overdenture Bar Frameworks with Different Fit Levels and Materials. Implant Dent, 30: 1019-1027
Spazzin, A.O., Santos, M.B.F., Sobrinho, L.C., Consani, R.L.X., Mesquita, M.F. (2011) Effects of Horizontal Misfit and Bar Framework Material on the Stress Distribution of an Overdenture-Retaining Bar System: A 3D Finite Element Analysis. J Prosthodont, 20: 517-522
Spazzin, A.O., Costa, A.R., Correr, A.B., Consani, R.L., Corrersobrinho, L., dos Santos, M.B. (2013) Effect of Bar Cross-Section Geometry on Stress Distribution in Overdenture-Retaining System Simulating Horizontal Misfit and Bone Loss. J Biomech, 46: 2039-2044
Timmerman, R., Stoker, G.T., Wismeijer, D., Oosterveld, P., Vermeeren, J.I.J.F., van Waas, M.A.J. (2004) An Eight-Year Follow-Up to a Randomized Clinical Trial of Participant Satisfaction with Three Types of Mandibular Implant-Retained Overdentures. J Dent Res, 83(8): 630-633
Topkaya, T., Solmaz, M.Y. (2015) The Effect of Implant Number and Position on the Stress Behavior of Mandibular Implant Retained Overdentures: A Three-Dimensional Finite Element Analysis. J Biomech, 48(10): 2102-2109
Waddell, J., Payne, A.G.T., Swain, M.V. (2006) Physical and Metallurgical Considerations of Failures of Soldered Bars in Bar Attachment Systems for Implant Overdentures: A Review of the Literature. J Prosthet Dent, 96(4): 283-288
Balkan Journal of Dental Medicine, 2022, vol. 26, br. 2, str. 93-99