Separated instrument in endodontics: Frequency, treatment and prognosis

Vouzara Triantafyllia, el Chares Maryam, Lyroudia Kleoniki

Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Faculty of Health Sciences, School of Dentistry, Department of Endodontology, Thessaloniki, Greece

Summary

Instrument separation during endodontic therapy is a frequent accident with rotary instruments being more likely to separate than manual ones. The treatment of cases with a separated instrument can be either conservative or surgical. A conservative approach involves the following treatment choices: a) bypass of the fragment, b) removal of the fragment, c) instrumentation and obturation coronally to the fragment. Concerning the removal of a separated instrument, a variety of techniques and systems have been developed. Ultrasonics, in combination with the operative microscope constitute the most effective and reliable tools for removing a separated endodontic instrument from a root canal. The likelihood of successful removal depends on: the level of separation (coronal, middle or apical third); location in relation to the root canal curvature; the type of separated instrument; its length; the degree of canal curvature and the tooth type. Several complications may occur during the management of a separated instrument: separation of the ultrasonic tip or file used for bypassing or removing the instrument; further separation of the fragment; perforation; ledge; extrusion of the file into periapical tissues; tooth weakening due to dentin removal, as well as excessive temperature rise in periodontal tissues. Prognosis for a tooth retaining a separated instrument depends on the presence of a periapical lesion, the microbial load of the root canal during the time of separation and the quality of the obturation.

Keywords: broken endodontic instrument; fractured endodontic instrument; separated endodontic instrument; treatment of instrument separation; prognosis of tooth with retained instrument

Reference

Aboud, L. R. L., Ormiga, F., Gomes, J. A. C. P. (2013) Electrochemical induced dissolution of fragments of nickel-titanium endodontic files and their removal from simulated root canals. International Endodontic Journal, 47(2): 155-162

Al-Fouzan, K. S. (2003) Incidence of rotary ProFile instrument fracture and the potential for bypassing in vivo. International Endodontic Journal, 36(12): 864-867

Alomairy, K.H. (2009) Evaluating Two Techniques on Removal of Fractured Rotary Nickel-Titanium Endodontic Instruments from Root Canals: An In Vitro Study. Journal of Endodontics, 35(4): 559-562

Amaral, C. C. F., Ormiga, F., Gomes, J. A. C. P. (2014) Electrochemical-induced dissolution of stainless steel files. International Endodontic Journal, 48(2): 137-144

Ankrum, M., Hartwell, G., Truitt, J. (2004) K3 Endo, ProTaper, and ProFile Systems: Breakage and Distortion in Severely Curved Roots of Molars. Journal of Endodontics, 30(4): 234-2373     Atrizadeh, F., Kennedy, J., Zander, H. (1971) Ankylosis of teeth following thermal injury. J Periodontal Res, 6(3): 159-67

Baumann, M.A., Roth, A. (1999) Effect of experience on quality of canal preparation with rotary nickel-titanium files. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontology, 88(6): 714-718

Budd, J. C., Gekelman, D., White, J. M. (2005) Temperature rise of the post and on the root surface during ultrasonic post removal. International Endodontic Journal, 38(10): 705-711

Cohen, S., Schwartz, S. (1987) Endodontic complications and the law. Journal of Endodontics, 13(4): 191-197Cohen, S.J., Glassman, G.D., Mounce, R. (2005) Rips, strips and broken tips: Handling the endodontic mishap. Oral Health, 10-20

Crump, M.C., Natkin, E. (1970) Relationship of Broken Root Canal Instruments to Endodontic Case Prognosis: A Clinical Investigation. Journal of the American Dental Association, 80(6): 1341-1347

Cujé, J., Bargholz, C., Hülsmann, M. (2010) The outcome of retained instrument removal in a specialist practice. International Endodontic Journal, 43(7): 545-554

Cunha, R.S., Junaid, A., Ensinas, P., Nudera, W., da Silveira, B.C.E. (2014) Assessment of the Separation Incidence of Reciprocating WaveOne Files: A Prospective Clinical Study. Journal of Endodontics, 40(7): 922-924

Cvikl, B., Klimscha, J., Holly, M., Zeitlinger, M., Gruber, R., Moritz, A. (2014) Removal of fractured endodontic instruments using an Nd: YAG laser. Quintessence Int, 45: 569-575

di Fiore, P. M., Genov, K. A., Komaroff, E., Li, Y., Lin, L. (2006) Nickel-titanium rotary instrument fracture: a clinical practice assessment. International Endodontic Journal, 39(9): 700-708

Dominici, J., Clark, S., Scheetz, J., Eleazer, P. (2005) Analysis of Heat Generation Using Ultrasonic Vibration for Post Removal. Journal of Endodontics, 31(4): 301-303

Eriksson, A.R., Albrektsson, T. (1983) Temperature threshold levels for heat-induced bone tissue injury: A vital-microscopic study in the rabbit. Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 50(1): 101-107

Fishelberg, G., Pawluk, J.W. (2004) Nickel-titanium rotary-file canal preparation and intracanal file separation. Compend Contin Educ Dent, 25:17-18, 20-22, 24, 47

Fors, U.G.H., Berg, J.-O. (1983) A method for the removal of broken endodontic instruments from root canals. Journal of Endodontics, 9(4): 156-159

Fu, M., Zhang, Z., Hou, B. (2011) Removal of Broken Files from Root Canals by Using Ultrasonic Techniques Combined with Dental Microscope: A Retrospective Analysis of Treatment Outcome. Journal of Endodontics, 37(5): 619-622

Gaffney, J.L., Lehman, J.W., Miles, M.J. (1981) Expanded use of the ultrasonic scaler. Journal of Endodontics, 7(5): 228-229

Gao, Y., Shen, Y., Zhou, X., Haapasalo, M. (2015) Remaining root dentin thickness in mesiobuccal canals of maxillary first molars after attempted removal of broken instrument fragments. Australian Endodontic Journal, 41(3): 122-127

Garg, H., Grewal, M.S. (2016) Cone-beam Computed Tomography Volumetric Analysis and Comparison of Dentin Structure Loss after Retrieval of Separated Instrument by Using Ultrasonic EMS and ProUltra Tips. Journal of Endodontics, 42(11): 1693-1698

Gencoglu, N., Helvacioglu, D. (2009) Comparison of the different techniques to remove fractured endodontic instruments from root canal systems. Eur J Dent, 3: 90-95

Gerek, M., Başer, E. D., Kayahan, M. B., Sunay, H., Kaptan, R. F., Bayırlı, G. (2011) Comparison of the force required to fracture roots vertically after ultrasonic and Masserann removal of broken instruments. International Endodontic Journal, 45(5): 429-434

Gettleman, B.H., Spriggs, K.A., Eldeeb, M.E., Messer, H.H. (1991) Removal of canal obstructions with the endo extractor. Journal of Endodontics, 17(12): 608-611

Gluskin, A.H., Ruddle, C.J., Zinman, E.J. (2005) Thermal injury through intraradicular heat transfer using ultrasonic devices: precautions and practical preventive strategies. J Am Dent Assoc, 136: 1286-1293

Hashem, A. (2007) Ultrasonic Vibration: Temperature Rise on External Root Surface during Broken Instrument Removal. Journal of Endodontics, 33(9): 1070-1073

Hulsmann, M., Herbst, U., Schafers, F. (2003) Comparative study of root-canal preparation using Lightspeed and Quantec SC rotary NiTi instruments. Int Endod J, 36(11): 748-56

Hülsmann, M., Schinkel, I. (1999) Influence of several factors on the success or failure of removal of fractured instruments from the root canal. Dental Traumatology, 15(6): 252-258

Hulsmann, M. (1993) Methods for removing metal obstructions from the root canal. Dental Traumatology, 9(6): 223-237

Hülsmann, M. (1994) Removal of fractured instruments using a combined automated/ultrasonic technique. Journal of Endodontics, 20(3): 144-146

Huttula, A.S., Tordik, P.A., Imamura, G., Eichmiller, F.C., McClanahan, S.B. (2006) The Effect of Ultrasonic Post Instrumentation on Root Surface Temperature. Journal of Endodontics, 32(11): 1085-1087

Iqbal, M.K., Kohli, M.R., Kim, J.S. (2006) A Retrospective Clinical Study of Incidence of Root Canal Instrument Separation in an Endodontics Graduate Program: A PennEndo Database Study. Journal of Endodontics, 32(11): 1048-1052

Iqbal, M.K., Rafailov, H., Kratchman, S.I., Karabucak, B. (2006) A Comparison of Three Methods for Preparing Centered Platforms Around Separated Instruments in Curved Canals. Journal of Endodontics, 32(1): 48-51

Kerekes, K., Tronstad, L. (1979) Long-term results of endodontic treatment performed with a standardized technique. J Endod, 5(3): 83-90

Knowles, K.I., Hammond, N.B., Biggs, S.G., Ibarrola, J.L. (2006) Incidence of Instrument Separation Using LightSpeed Rotary Instruments. Journal of Endodontics, 32(1): 14-16

Kowalczuck, A., Silva, N.U. X., Fariniuk, L. F., Westphalen, V. P. D., Laurindo, C. A. H., Carneiro, E. (2016) Electrochemical dissolution of fractured nickel-titanium instruments in human extracted teeth. International Endodontic Journal, 50(6): 578-585

Kuttler, S., Mclean, A., Dorn, S., Fischzang, A. (2004) The impact of post space preparation with Gates-Glidden drills on residual dentin thickness in distal roots of mandibular molars. Journal of the American Dental Association, 135(7): 903-909

Lambrianidis, T. (2001) Risk management in root canal treatment. Thessaloniki: University Studio Press 

Line, S.E., Polson, A.M., Zander, H.A. (1974) Relationship between periodontal injury, selective cell repopulation and ankylosis. J Periodontol, 45(10): 725-30

Madarati, A. A., Qualtrough, A. J. E., Watts, D. C. (2010) Endodontists experience using ultrasonics for removal of intra-canal fractured instruments. International Endodontic Journal, 43(4): 301-305

Madarati, A. A., Watts, D. C., Qualtrough, A. J. E. (2008) Opinions and attitudes of endodontists and general dental practitioners in the UK towards the intracanal fracture of endodontic instruments: part 1. International Endodontic Journal, 41(8): 693-701

Madarati, A. A., Qualtrough, A. J. E., Watts, D. C. (2010) Effect of retained fractured instruments on tooth resistance to vertical fracture with or without attempt at removal. International Endodontic Journal, 43(11): 1047-1053

Madarati, A. A., Qualtrough, A. J. E., Watts, D. C. (2010) Vertical fracture resistance of roots after ultrasonic removal of fractured instruments. International Endodontic Journal, 43(5): 424-429

Madarati, A.A., Qualtrough, A.J.E., Watts, D.C. (2009) A Microcomputed Tomography Scanning Study of Root Canal Space: Changes after the Ultrasonic Removal of Fractured Files. Journal of Endodontics, 35(1): 125-128

Madarati, A.A., Hunter, M.J., Dummer, P.M.H. (2013) Management of Intracanal Separated Instruments. Journal of Endodontics, 39(5): 569-581

Madarati, A.A., Qualtrough, A.J., Watts, D.C. (2008) Factors Affecting Temperature Rise on the External Root Surface During Ultrasonic Retrieval of Intracanal Separated Files. Journal of Endodontics, 34(9): 1089-1092

Madarati, A.A., Qualtrough, A.J.E., Watts, D.C. (2009) Efficiency of a Newly Designed Ultrasonic Unit and Tips in Reducing Temperature Rise on Root Surface During the Removal of Fractured Files. Journal of Endodontics, 35(6): 896-899

Mitchell, Q., Jeansonne, B.G., Stoute, D., Lallier, T.E. (2013) Electrochemical Dissolution of Nickel-Titanium Endodontic Files Induces Periodontal Ligament Cell Death. Journal of Endodontics, 39(5): 679-684

Nagai, O., Tani, N., Kayaba, Y., Kodama, S., Osada, T. (1986) Ultrasonic removal of broken instruments in root canals. International Endodontic Journal, 19(6): 298-304

Nevares, G., Cunha, R.S., Zuolo, M.L., da Silveira, B.C.E. (2012) Success Rates for Removing or Bypassing Fractured Instruments: A Prospective Clinical Study. Journal of Endodontics, 38(4): 442-444

Ormiga, F., da Cunha, P.G.J.A., de Araújo, M.C.P. (2010) Dissolution of Nickel-Titanium Endodontic Files via an Electrochemical Process: A New Concept for Future Retrieval of Fractured Files in Root Canals. Journal of Endodontics, 36(4): 717-720

Ormiga, F., da Cunha, P.G.J.A., de Araújo, M.C.P., Barbosa, A.O.G. (2011) An Initial Investigation of the Electrochemical Dissolution of Fragments of Nickel-Titanium Endodontic Files. Journal of Endodontics, 37(4): 526-530

Panitvisai, P., Parunnit, P., Sathorn, C., Messer, H.H. (2010) Impact of a Retained Instrument on Treatment Outcome: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Journal of Endodontics, 36(5): 775-780

Park, E. (2013) Ultrasonics in endodontics. Endodontic Topics, 29(1): 125-159

Plotino, G., Pameijer, C., Mariagrande, N., Somma, F. (2007) Ultrasonics in Endodontics: A Review of the Literature. Journal of Endodontics, 33(2): 81-95

Raiden, G., Koss, S., Costa, L., Hernandez, J. (2001) Radiographic Measurement of Residual Root Thickness in Premolars with Post Preparation. Journal of Endodontics, 27(4): 296-298

Ramirez-Salomon, M., Soler-Bientz, R., de la Garza-González, R., Palacios-Garza, C.M. (1997) Incidence of lightspeed separation and the potential for bypassing. Journal of Endodontics, 23(9): 586-587

Roda, R.S., Gettleman, B.H. (2011) Nonsurgical Retreatment. u: Cohen's Pathways of the Pulp, Elsevier BV, str. 890-952

Roig-Greene, J.L. (1983) The retrieval of foreign objects from root canals: A Simple aid. Journal of Endodontics, 9(9): 394-3971   Ruddle, C. (2004) Nonsurgical Retreatment. Journal of Endodontics, 30(12): 827-845

Ruddle, C.J. (1997) Micro-endodontic non-surgical retreatment. Dent Clin North Am, 41: 429-454

Saunders, E. M., Saunders, W. P. (1989) The heat generated on the external root surface during post space preparation. International Endodontic Journal, 22(4): 169-173

Saunders, E. M. (1990) In vivo findings associated with heat generation during thermomechanical compactionof gutta-percha. Part II. Histological response to temperature elevation on the external surface of the root. International Endodontic Journal, 23(5): 268-274

Shahabinejad, H., Ghassemi, A., Pishbin, L., Shahravan, A. (2013) Success of Ultrasonic Technique in Removing Fractured Rotary Nickel-Titanium Endodontic Instruments from Root Canals and Its Effect on the Required Force for Root Fracture. Journal of Endodontics, 39(6): 824-828

Shen, Y., Peng, B., Cheung, G.S. (2004) Factors associated with the removal of fractured NiTi instruments from root canal systems. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontology, 98(5): 605-610

Sigurdsson, A. (2002) Evaluation of success and failure. u: Walton R., Torabinejad M. [ur.] Priciples and Practice of Endodontics, Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders Company, p. 331-344

Simon, S., Machtou, P., Tomson, P., Adams, N., Lumley, P. (2008) Influence of Fractured Instruments on the Success Rate of Endodontic Treatment.Dental Update, 35(3): 172-179

Sleiman, W.P. (2006) The use of a chelating agent and ultrasonic tips in the retrieval of broken rotary NiTi. Oral health, 49-53

Souter, N., Messer, H. (2005) Complications Associated with Fractured File Removal Using an Ultrasonic Technique. Journal of Endodontics, 31(6): 450-452

Souyave, L.C., Inglis, A.T., Alcalay, M. (1985) Removal of fractured endodontic instruments using ultrasonics. British Dental Journal, 159(8): 251-25

Spili, P., Parashos, P., Messer, H.H. (2005) The impact of instrument fracture on outcome of endodontic treatment. Journal of endodontics, 31(12): 845-50

Spriggs, K., Gettleman, B., Messer, H.H. (1990) Evaluation of a new method for silver point removal. Journal of Endodontics, 16(7): 335-338

Strindberg, L.Z. (1956) The dependence of the results of pulp therapy on certain factors: an analysis study based on radiographic and clinical follow up examination. Acta Odontol Scand, 14: 1-175

Suter, B., Lussi, A., Sequeira, P. (2005) Probability of removing fractured instruments from root canals. International Endodontic Journal, 38(2): 112-123

Suter, B. (1998) A new method for retrieving silver points and separated instruments from root canals. Journal of Endodontics, 24(6): 446-448

Terauchi, Y., o`Leary Le,, Suda, H. (2006) Removal of Separated Files from Root Canals With a New File-removal System: Case Reports. Journal of Endodontics, 32(8): 789-797

Terauchi, Y., o`Leary Le,, Yoshioka, T., Suda, H. (2013) Comparison of the Time Required to Create Secondary Fracture of Separated File Fragments by Using Ultrasonic Vibration under Various Canal Conditions. Journal of Endodontics, 39(10): 1300-1305

Terauchi, Y., o`Leary Le,, Kikuchi, I., Asanagi, M., Yoshioka, T., Kobayashi, C., Suda, H. (2007) Evaluation of the Efficiency of a New File Removal System in Comparison With Two Conventional Systems. Journal of Endodontics, 33(5): 585-588

Tilk, M.A., Lommel, T.J., Gerstein, H. (1979) A study of mandibular and maxillary root widths to determine dowel size. J Endod, 5(3): 79-82Torabinejad, M., Lemon, R.R. (2002) Procedural accidents. u: Walton R., Torabinejad M. [ur.] Priciples and Practice of Endodontics, Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders Company, p. 310-330

Tzanetakis, G.N., Kontakiotis, E.G., Maurikou, D.V., Marzelou, M.P. (2008) Prevalence and Management of Instrument Fracture in the Postgraduate Endodontic Program at the Dental School of Athens: A Five-year Retrospective Clinical Study. Journal of Endodontics, 34(6): 675-678

Ungerechts, C., Bårdsen, A., Fristad, I. (2013) Instrument fracture in root canals - where, why, when and what? A study from a student clinic. International Endodontic Journal, 47(2): 183-190

Wang, N., Ge, J., Xie, S., Chen, G., Zhu, M. (2014) Analysis of Mtwo Rotary Instrument Separation During Endodontic Therapy: A Retrospective Clinical Study. Cell Biochemistry and Biophysics, 70(2): 1091-1095

Ward, J., Parashos, P., Messer, H. (2003) Evaluation of an Ultrasonic Technique to Remove Fractured Rotary Nickel-Titanium Endodontic Instruments from Root Canals: Clinical Cases. Journal of Endodontics, 29(11): 764-767

Weisman, M.I. (1983) The removal of difficult silver cones. Journal of Endodontics, 9(5): 210-211

Wolcott, S., Wolcott, J., Ishley, D., Kennedy, W., Johnson, S., Minnich, S., Meyers, J. (2006) Separation Incidence of Protaper Rotary Instruments: A Large Cohort Clinical Evaluation. Journal of Endodontics, 32(12): 1139-1141

Wu, J., Lei, G., Yan, M., Yu, Y., Yu, J., Zhang, G. (2011) Instrument Separation Analysis of Multi-used ProTaper Universal Rotary System during Root Canal Therapy. Journal of Endodontics, 37(6): 758-763

Wu, M., van der Sluis, L.W.M., Wesselink, P.R. (2005) The risk of furcal perforation in mandibular molars using Gates-Glidden drills with anticurvature pressure. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod, 99(3): 378-82

Yang, Q., Cheung, G.S., Shen, Y., Huang, D., Zhou, X., Gao, Y. (2015) The remaining dentin thickness investigation of the attempt to remove broken instrument from mesiobuccal canals of maxillary first molars with virtual simulation technique. BMC Oral Health, 15(1):

Yoldas, O., Oztunc, H., Tinaz, C., Alparslan, N. (2004) Perforation risks associated with the use of Masserann endodontic kit drills in mandibular molars. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontology, 97(4): 513-517

Yu, D., Kimura, Y., Tomita, Y., Nakamura, Y., Watanabe, H., Matsumoto, K. (2000) Study on Removal Effects of Filling Materials and Broken Files from Root Canals Using Pulsed Nd:YAG Laser. Journal of Clinical Laser Medicine & Surgery, 18(1): 23-28

Zuckerman, O., Katz, A., Pilo, R., Tamse, A., Fuss, Z. (2003) Residual dentin thickness in mesial roots of mandibular molars prepared with Lightspeed rotary instruments and Gates-Glidden reamers. Oral surgery, oral medicine, oral pathology, oral radiology, and endodontics, 96(3): 351-5

Balkan Journal of Dental Medicine, 2018, vol. 22, br. 3, str. 123-132